“Non compensatory entitlement occurs when the support obligation arises from the marriage relationship itself when a spouse is unable to become self-sufficient. It can be based on need. Under this model, spousal support will be based on economic hardship resulting from the breakdown of the marriage, but not necessarily the roles assumed during the marriage. The needs based support could, therefore, consider the recipient’s ability to become self-sufficient for reasons such as health.
In determining need, courts ought to be guided in part by the principle that the spouse receiving support is entitled to maintain the standard of living to which she was accustomed at the time cohabitation ceased. The analysis must consider the recipient’s ability to support herself, in light of her income and reasonable expenses. Gray v. Gray, 2014 ONCA 659.
In Ford v. Waldhart, 2022 ONSC 6277, the court said:
Entitlement on a needs basis will generally be found in cases where there is a significant income disparity at the time of the initial application. See: Spousal Support Advisory Guidelines: The Revised User’s Guide, April 2016: Professor Carol Rogerson and Professor Rollie Thompson (“SSAGs”). In the case before me, there is a large discrepancy in the parties’ incomes (regardless of whether I accept the Husband’s calculations or the Wife’s calculations of the Wife’s income).I find that the Husband suffered an economic hardship as a result of the breakdown of the long-term relationship. There is no question that the Husband cannot afford to maintain a standard of living similar to that enjoyed by the parties during the relationship.”