July 5, 2019 – Delay In Bringing Claim

“It has been oft repeated that there is no limitation period for an application for spousal support. However extreme delay in bringing the application can defeat or diminish such a claim. As Chappel J. of this court put it in Fyfe v. Jouppien, following an exhaustive review of the relevant factors in determining whether delay should defeat or reduce a spousal support claim:

…excessive delay in seeking spousal support by a party may raise questions as to whether there was an ongoing reasonable expectation of support, and whether there was actual need on the part of the claimant spouse.

Chappel J. set out a number of important factors that a court must consider in the face of extreme delay. They include financial need arising after separation, financial interdependence, both before and particularly after separation, and the length of the delay in making the claim.

While delay may indicate that the parties have taken steps to unravel their financial interdependence, that is not always the case. As Chappel J. stated at para. 54(d):

On the other hand, the passage of time may be given less weight in the analysis of entitlement if, despite the passage of a number of years, the parties have not effected a clean break, and their relationship continues to be characterized by mutuality and interdependence. In such circumstances, an objective analysis of the situation may lead to the conclusion that the expectation of mutual support and dependency arising from the marriage relationship has continued.”

Karlovic v. Karlovic, 2018 ONSC 4233 (CanLII) at 56-58