November 17, 2026 – Needs-Based Spousal Support

“Bracklow v. Bracklow, 1999 CanLII 715 (SCC), [1999] 1 SCR 420, remains a leading authority on the non-compensatory basis for spousal support. The fundamental principles set out in Bracklow were concisely summarized by Chappel, J. in Fyfe v. Jouppien, 2011 ONSC 5462, at para. 48:

          1.    The presumption in marriage is that spouses owe each other a mutual duty of support.  This presumption of mutual support is rebuttable. Parties to a marriage may alter this presumption, either through explicit contracting or through the structuring of their daily affairs, to show disavowal of financial interweaving.
          2.    When a marriage breaks down, the presumption of mutual support no longer applies.
          3.    Marriage does not, in and of itself, automatically entitle a spouse to support.  It is not the bare fact of marriage so much as the relationship that is established and the expectations that may reasonably flow from it that give rise to the obligation of spousal support under the statutes.
          4.    In Bracklow, the Court emphasized the importance of analyzing the nature of the parties’ relationship during the marriage to determine whether there was any evidence as of the separation date to rebut the presumption of mutuality and interdependence in the parties’ relationship.  This analysis must start with a presumption of interdependence between the parties.

In Lazare v. Heitner, 2018 ONSC 3604, at paragraphs 27 and 28, McGee, J. observed that the nature of a spousal relationship may shift or alternate over the course of marriage.  If a spouse is financially dependent when the marriage ends, the Divorce Act requires that spouse to make reasonable efforts to return to independence, or if independence is no longer possible, the highest measure available. Non-compensatory support primarily addresses the financial need of a dependent, lower income earning spouse by asking what amount within the means of the higher earning spouse over what period of time, ought to be paid to support the journey towards financial independence.  In other words, what amount, paid over what period of time will recognize the nature of the failed relationship, relieve resulting economic hardship and promote self-sufficiency?

In Gray v. Gray, 2014 ONCA 659, at para. 27, the Court stated that need, in the context of relieving economic hardship, should be assessed through the lens of viewing marriage as an economic partnership. In determining need, courts ought to be guided in part by the principle that the spouse receiving support is entitled to maintain the standard of living to which he/she was accustomed at the time cohabitation ceased. The analysis must consider the recipient’s ability to support himself/herself, in light of his/her income and reasonable expenses.”

Scheibler v. Scheibler, 2022 ONSC 6472 (CanLII) at 126-128

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *